Once you're shopping in the premium putter tier, the decision usually isn't about performance specs — all three of these brands make putters that roll the ball beautifully. It's about feel, and feel is genuinely personal.
Here's what actually separates Scotty Cameron, Bettinardi and Odyssey, so you know what you're choosing between before you spend on a used premium putter.
Our putter stock is sourced from Osaka and local trade-ins, honestly graded, and shipped Australia-wide from Adelaide.
What's the Real Difference Between These Three Brands?
| Brand | Known for | Typical feel |
|---|---|---|
| Scotty Cameron | Precision milling, classic blade and mid-mallet shapes, strong resale value | Firm, crisp, traditional feedback |
| Bettinardi | Hand-milled construction, soft-feeling face technology | Soft, buttery feel at impact |
| Odyssey | Insert-face technology (White Hot, Stroke Lab), widest range of mallet shapes | Softer, more forgiving feel with a distinct sound |
Blade or Mallet — Which Should You Buy?
This matters more than the brand badge. A blade putter (classic Scotty Cameron shapes, some Bettinardi models) suits golfers with an arcing stroke and gives more feedback on off-centre hits — useful if you want to feel your misses and self-correct. A mallet (many Odyssey shapes, some Bettinardi and Scotty models) is more forgiving on strikes that miss the centre and tends to suit a straighter putting stroke. If you're not sure which stroke type you have, a mallet is the more forgiving starting point.
Does Feel Actually Matter, or Is It Just Marketing?
It matters more for putters than almost any other club, because putting is entirely about touch and distance control — there's no swing speed or launch angle to compensate for a putter that doesn't suit you. A putter you have confidence in and enjoy hitting will get more practice reps from you than one that feels "correct" on paper but doesn't suit your hands. That's a genuine performance factor, not just preference for its own sake.
Is It Worth Buying a Premium Putter Used?
Very much so — putters depreciate less on feel than any other club in the bag, since there's no swing-speed-driven technology to become outdated. A well-cared-for used Scotty Cameron, Bettinardi or Odyssey rolls the ball exactly as well today as it did when new; you're mainly paying for cosmetic condition, not lost performance. Check the face for gouges and the alignment lines for clarity, and cosmetic wear is otherwise mostly a non-issue.
FAQ
Is Bettinardi better than Scotty Cameron?
Neither is objectively "better" — Bettinardi is known for a softer, hand-milled feel, while Scotty Cameron is known for firmer, crisper feedback. It comes down to which feel suits your stroke and preference.
Should I buy a blade or mallet putter?
A mallet is generally more forgiving on off-centre strikes and suits a straighter stroke. A blade gives more feedback and suits golfers with an arcing stroke who want to feel their misses.
Do premium putters lose performance over time when bought used?
No — putters depreciate on cosmetics far more than performance. A well-maintained used premium putter rolls the ball just as well as when it was new.
What should I check before buying a used premium putter?
Face condition (no gouges affecting the strike surface), alignment lines for clarity, and headcover/grip condition — grips are cheap to replace if worn.
Browse our current putter range — or take 5% off your first order with code THREEPUTT.